|
Everyone watched Friday’s inflation report. The number that matters more came out the same morning and was ignored: the second-worst consumer mood in 74 years.
| |
|
|
|
September 12, 2026 • Weekend edition • No hype, just perspective.
|
|
Everyone Watched the Inflation Report Friday. The Number That Mattered More Was Ignored.
The same morning as the CPI, a survey showed American consumer confidence at its second-lowest level in 74 years, with inflation expectations jumping to 4.6 percent. That gap, between what the data says and what people believe, is what actually forces the Fed’s hand on Wednesday.
|
|
RATE INCREASE COMING? Why Your Power Bill Is Set to Rise Something new is plugging into the power grid and draining it — something that can devour the electricity of 100,000 homes at once, likely being built in your state right now. In some states, bills are already up 20% in a year, and James Altucher believes that's just the start. So he's identified the one company in prime position to facilitate a plan that’ll let you flip this rate hike into a profit. Get the details in James' FREE briefing now. |
|
|
The Scoreboard
|
• Second-worst ever: The University of Michigan’s consumer sentiment index fell to 47.8 in September, down from 51.7 in August and below the 51 expected. It is the second-lowest reading in records going back to 1952, behind only this past May.
• The expectations jump: Americans now expect prices to rise 4.6 percent over the next year, up from 4.0 percent a month ago, the highest since June. Official inflation is 3.4 percent, so the public expects far more than the data shows.
• Broad and bipartisan: Sentiment dropped among both Democrats and Republicans. The survey’s director tied it to gas prices at a record high for September and to trade tensions.
• The context: Sentiment now sits 16 percent below February, before the Iran conflict began, and 13 percent below a year ago. The gauge for year-ahead expectations dropped sharply.
• Why it matters now: The Fed decides Wednesday, with a hike near 87 percent priced in. Slipping inflation expectations are exactly what a central bank moves to stop.
|
|
|
Details
|
The loud number was the CPI. The one that moves the next year was the quiet survey
Everyone spent Friday watching the inflation report. The number that mattered more came out the same morning and barely made the news. While the financial world dissected the Consumer Price Index and debated whether the Fed hikes on Wednesday, the University of Michigan released its monthly survey of how Americans actually feel about the economy. The answer: worse than at almost any point in the last seventy-four years. The sentiment index fell to 47.8, the second-lowest reading ever recorded, in data going back to 1952. Only one month in American history was gloomier, and that was this past May.
Sit with that for a moment. Not the 2008 financial crisis, not the depths of the pandemic, not the inflation scare a few years ago. Americans are more pessimistic about the economy right now than in almost all of them.
Here is why the quiet number matters more, and it comes down to a single gap. The government says inflation is running at 3.4 percent. But the same survey found ordinary Americans expect prices to rise 4.6 percent over the next year, up sharply from 4.0 percent a month ago, and the highest reading since June. That gap, between the official 3.4 and the felt 4.6, is the most important thing in this report, because inflation expectations are not just an opinion. They are a fuse. When people believe prices will keep climbing, they act on it: they ask for bigger raises, they accept higher prices before they climb further, they buy now rather than later. Each of those behaviors pushes actual prices up, which confirms the fear, which repeats the cycle.
Economists call this an unanchoring of expectations, and it is the single thing a central banker fears most, because once it takes hold it is brutally hard to reverse.
One company sits at the dead-center of Elon's AI takeover… And James Altucher believes this takeover could mint as many as 1.8 million new "Musk Millionaires." It's not Tesla, SpaceX, or even a company Elon currently owns. It's a name almost nobody's talking about — and it still trades for less than $100. James put the whole prediction into his FREE Millionaire Maker Masterclass… including details on exactly what Elon filed with the FCC and how you can position yourself before September 25. Join his FREE masterclass right now.
This is the box the Fed is trapped in, and it explains next week. Chair Kevin Warsh has spent weeks warning he is not convinced inflation is beaten. Friday handed him the proof: not just a hot inflation number, but a public whose expectations are visibly slipping loose. A hike on Wednesday is now nearly certain, and this survey is a large part of why. The Fed is not raising rates because the economy is strong. It is raising them because the public has stopped believing prices will behave, and a central bank that loses control of what people expect has lost the game. It must act to prove it still can.
Now bring it home, because you are on both sides of this. You are the consumer in that survey, feeling the same 4.6 percent bite at the pump and the grocery store that everyone else feels, whatever the official 3.4 says. And you are the investor whose portfolio depends on what the Fed does about it. Those two roles pull in opposite directions. As a consumer, the pain argues for relief, for lower rates. As an investor watching the Fed, the slipping expectations argue for the opposite, for a central bank that tightens harder to reassert control. When those forces collide, borrowing stays expensive precisely when household budgets are most stretched, and that squeeze is the real story of this economy right now.
So what does a steady hand do with a weekend like this, sitting between a grim consumer and a determined Fed. It stops treating the CPI as the only number that matters and starts watching the one that measures belief, because expectations are what turn a temporary price spike into lasting inflation. It positions for a central bank more worried about its credibility than about growth, which means rates that stay high longer than the tired hope for cuts assumes. And it remembers that a consumer this pessimistic eventually spends less, which cools the economy on its own. None of this is investment advice.
The loudest number this week was the inflation report. The one that will shape the next year was the quiet survey of how far Americans have stopped trusting that prices will ever settle. Watch what people believe. It moves the world more reliably than what the data says.
|
|
Harold Winston
Thirty years reading markets for a living.
No hype, just perspective.
|
|
|
|
